The SEC adopted a rulemaking package designed to enhance retail investors' protections when dealing with broker-dealers and investment advisers. The rulemaking package consists of (i) Regulation Best Interest, (ii) the Form CRS Relationship Summary, (iii) an interpretation of investment advisers' fiduciary duty, and (iv) an interpretation of the "solely incidental" prong of the broker-dealer exclusion under the Advisers Act. The rules and forms will become effective 60 days following publication in the Federal Register, with a transition period lasting until June 30, 2020. The interpretations will become effective upon publication in the Federal Register.
Regulation Best Interest ("Reg. BI") will require broker-dealers not to prioritize their interests ahead of customers' when making recommendations regarding a securities transaction, investment strategy or account recommendation. The regulation provides that a broker-dealer will satisfy the best interest standard if it complies with the following obligations:
Disclosure: disclose material information about the relationship and recommendations, including material conflicts of interest;
Care: act with reasonable "diligence, care and skill" when making a recommendation by (i) understanding potential risks, rewards and costs, (ii) evaluating the recommendation against the customer's interests, (iii) advising based on the customer's best interests, and (iv) explicitly considering any associated costs;
Conflict of Interest: establish policies and procedures reasonably designed to identify and address conflicts of interest that will (i) monitor conflicts that incentivize professionals to prioritize their interests over customers', (ii) prevent material limitations on offerings from incentivizing professionals to prioritize their interests over customers', and (iii) remove any incentives for professionals (i.e., sales contests, sales quotas, bonuses, and non-cash compensation) that rely on the sale of specific securities or types of securities within a time-limited period; and
Compliance: implement policies and procedures that comply with Reg. BI as a whole.
Reg. BI also imposes recordkeeping requirements relating to retail customer information.
At the beginning of their relationship with retail investors, investment advisers and broker-dealers will be required to deliver the Form CRS Relationship Summary. According to the SEC, the summary will provide key information about the firm and include a standardized question-and-answer format to help investors compare the different types of firms.
In the investment adviser interpretation, the SEC reaffirms and clarifies certain aspects of the fiduciary duty that investment advisers owe to their clients. These fiduciary duty requirements include (i) the "duty of care," which includes the obligation to provide advice in a client's best interest, the duty to seek best execution, and the duty to provide advice and monitoring over the course of the relationship, and (ii) the "duty of loyalty," which requires that an adviser not place its own interests ahead of its client's interests.
Additionally, the SEC clarified the exemption under the Advisers Act that excludes certain broker-dealers from the definition of investment adviser (a.k.a. the "solely incidental" interpretation). Specifically, a broker-dealer is excluded from the definition, even if it is providing advice on the value and characteristics of securities or securities transactions, so long as the advice is provided in connection with, and is reasonably related to, its primary business and it receives no special compensation.
SEC Chair Jay Clayton expressed his support for the rulemaking package and characterized criticism against the package as "misguided." Mr. Clayton responded to specific criticisms, saying that (i) Reg. BI cannot be implemented through disclosures alone, (ii) the Form CRS Relationship Summary is a huge improvement over existing disclosures for investors, and (iii) the fiduciary interpretation does not weaken the existing fiduciary duty for investment advisers.
SEC Commissioner Robert J. Jackson Jr. dissented, saying that the rulemaking package does not raise the standard for investment advice. Specifically, Mr. Jackson stated that the package "retain[s] a muddled standard that exposes millions of Americans to the costs of conflicted advice." Additionally, he criticized the rulemaking's inference that investment advisers are not true fiduciaries.
SEC Investor Advocate Rick Fleming stated that, while Reg. BI is a step in the right direction, the rulemaking package contains notable issues. According to Mr. Fleming, (i) the fiduciary interpretation undermines investor protections, (ii) the Form CRS relationship summary is likely to confuse investors, and (iii) the "solely incidental" interpretation does not better clarify the distinction between broker-dealers and investment advisers but, rather merely formalizes the SEC's longstanding deference to certain broker-dealer activities.
SEC Commissioner Elad L. Roisman approved of the rulemaking package and advised the SEC to work with the industry and the public to complete a smooth transition.
Cadwalader attorneys authored a memorandum on the implications of the recently proposed SEC releases that are intended to expand and clarify the duties that broker-dealers and investment advisers owe to their clients under the Exchange Act.
The SEC proposed rules (i) to require broker-dealers to act in the "best interests" of retail customers when making investment recommendations and (ii) to affirm and clarify the various types of obligations that investment advisers owe to their clients.
Available only to Cabinet Premium subscribers.
Combining regulatory and enforcement news, analysis, and practical work tools on an easy-to-use digital platform.